Lavin Claims Victory as Democrats Secure Key Wins in Amherst

Shawn Lavin has emerged victorious in the race for Town Supervisor of Amherst, defeating Republican challenger Dan Gagliardo on November 4, 2025. As the current Deputy Town Supervisor and Councilmember, Lavin’s win marks a significant shift in leadership, taking over from outgoing Supervisor Brian Kulpa, who is stepping down due to term limits.

The election night results reflect a broader success for the Democratic Party in Amherst. Alongside Lavin, John Davis and Jack Kavanaugh secured the top two spots in the race for two Town Board seats, defeating Republican candidates John Trabert and Mary Dormer. This outcome highlights a continuing trend of Democratic strength in the local political landscape.

Gagliardo, addressing supporters at the Erie County Republican Committee’s headquarters in Williamsville, expressed gratitude for the campaign experience. He noted, “I actually got better. I listened more. I had more empathy towards the residents out there, and we can only hope that they’re going to do the exact same thing when they’re in office.” His acknowledgment of the need for ongoing scrutiny of elected officials resonated with attendees.

In his victory speech, Lavin recognized the competitive nature of the race, stating, “It was a spirited campaign, and I appreciate his gumption. Anybody who puts themselves out there, it’s not easy. I appreciate the race he ran.”

Kulpa, reflecting on his tenure, described his feelings as bittersweet. He emphasized the challenges he faced, including revitalizing property development in the area. “We had to get properties moving. We had to get redevelopment reignited,” he remarked. “We needed to turn the corner from watching property values plateau and drop off, and start seeing opportunities for people, expand their investments and see their opportunities for housing.”

As Davis and Kavanaugh celebrated their victories, Trabert and Dormer expressed disappointment but remained optimistic about the future. Trabert articulated hopes for the new administration, stating, “I hope that they work on the debt. I hope they work on the services. I hope they work on representing the people and serving the people.”

The results of this election not only reshape the leadership in Amherst but also set the stage for the Democratic Party to pursue its agenda in the coming term. With Lavin at the helm, residents will be keenly observing how the new administration addresses local concerns and priorities.