Judge Remy Smith Launches Campaign for Richmond County Civil Court

A significant political campaign has begun on Staten Island as Housing Court Judge Remy Smith officially announced her candidacy for the Richmond County Civil Court. The launch event took place on the afternoon of October 15, 2023, at the Staten Island Civil Courthouse in West Brighton, where Smith was supported by prominent figures from the borough’s Republican leadership.

During her speech, Smith emphasized her commitment to core community values, stating, “These are simple values: wanting to peacefully go to our house of worship, going to a concert in the neighborhood, taking our kids to a sports practice.” She framed the upcoming election as a pivotal moment for voters to choose leaders who will uphold these principles.

Smith, a lifelong resident of Staten Island, highlighted her extensive legal experience and her dedication to fair judicial practices. “When I make a decision, it’s based on the law as written,” she explained. “I can interpret the law, I can use my common sense and I can consult with the Constitution, but I absolutely cannot just make up a law because it’s the decision I feel better about.”

Supporters of Smith, including Assemblymember Michael Tannousis, who chairs the Staten Island Republican Party, framed the Civil Court race within the larger context of political maneuvering. Tannousis alleged that the seat was created by Democrats to secure an easier win, asserting, “The reason why we’re going to concentrate especially on this seat are because of the dirty tricks that the Democratic Party tried to pull in Albany.”

Assemblymember Sam Pirozzolo echoed this sentiment, asserting that justice should remain impartial. “Justice is supposed to be blind, and that’s what we’re going to do when we advance Judge Smith to the Civil Court,” he stated.

The significance of this election extends beyond the Civil Court, as indicated by newly elected Councilman Frank Morano. He described the race as a “crossroads,” suggesting that a Republican victory in this competitive district could send a powerful message throughout New York City. “If the Republicans can win in this district, a solidly purple district… we’re sending the message to Republicans all over New York City that if we can win here we can win anywhere,” Morano said.

Among those supporting Smith was Assemblymember Michael Reilly, who emphasized the importance of electing representatives who align with community values. “Staten Island, you want people that represent your values, your Republican values, because that’s why we’re together as a team,” Reilly noted.

Smith faces a competitive race against Matthew Santamauro, a seasoned attorney who officially launched his campaign in June. Santamauro, who will appear on the Democratic line, has a background as an assistant district attorney for the Richmond County District Attorney’s Office and previously founded his own legal practice specializing in criminal and injury law. He previously ran unsuccessfully for the Civil Court in 2022.

The Richmond County Civil Court seat, which Smith and Santamauro are vying for, encompasses much of Staten Island’s North and West shores, with the East and South shores forming the other district. This seat was previously held by Robert Helbock, who now serves as the supervising judge for Staten Island Civil Court.

As the election approaches in November 2023, the stakes are high for both candidates, with implications that could resonate beyond Staten Island.