Vice President JD Vance Questions Turkey Traditions at Thanksgiving

Vice President JD Vance stirred conversation at Fort Campbell, Kentucky, on November 26, 2025, during a Thanksgiving meal served to U.S. military service members. In his remarks, Vance humorously questioned the widespread affection for turkey, a staple of the holiday, leading to mixed reactions from the audience and online commentators.

While serving the holiday meal, Vance posed the provocative question, “Who really likes, be honest with yourself, who really likes turkey?” He challenged the attendees, suggesting that many who raised their hands were not being truthful. “How many times do you roast an 18-pound turkey just randomly?” he continued, pointing out that it is not a common practice outside of the Thanksgiving holiday.

Vance’s comments were intended to be light-hearted. He acknowledged the tradition of preparing turkey for Thanksgiving, stating, “On the most American holiday, we’re gonna cook a turkey, by God, because that’s what Americans do.” His remarks aimed to engage military personnel in a festive spirit, but many perceived the delivery as lacking in charisma.

Reactions to the Vice President’s Remarks

The Vice President’s humor did not land as intended for some. Critics took to social media to express their disappointment, with one comment noting he was “doing 2014 Twitter discourse in real life,” while another remarked, “He’s trying to do bits like Trump and flopping so hard.” This feedback highlights the challenges public figures face when attempting to blend humor with serious occasions.

While his remarks may have sparked debate about Thanksgiving traditions, they also served as a reminder of the ongoing cultural conversations surrounding the holiday. In the United States, Thanksgiving is a time for families to gather and reflect, but it also raises discussions about historical context and contemporary relevance.

Vance’s visit was part of a broader effort to connect with military personnel during the holiday season, aiming to provide them with a sense of normalcy and celebration in their service. Despite the mixed reactions, his appearance at Fort Campbell underscores the importance of acknowledging and celebrating those who serve.

As the holiday season approaches, discussions like these reflect the complexities of traditions and the evolving narratives surrounding them. Whether or not turkey remains the centerpiece of Thanksgiving, the day continues to be an occasion for gathering, gratitude, and reflection for many across the nation.