Hoka Challenger 8: Versatile All-Terrain Shoe Tested Over 40 Miles

The Hoka Challenger 8, launched in July 2025, has drawn attention as a versatile running shoe suitable for both road and trail use. Priced at $155 in the U.S. and £130 in the U.K., it provides a compelling option for runners who navigate mixed terrains.

Designed for training on varied surfaces, the Challenger 8 offers more grip than typical road shoes while providing a more comfortable experience than many trail shoes. This makes it an ideal choice for runners who must traverse urban pathways before hitting the trails.

Design and Comfort

Available in four colors, including a striking white model, the Challenger 8 fits true to size and comes in two width options, though not all colors are offered in both widths. The shoe features an increased heel-to-toe drop of 8mm, compared to the 5mm of its predecessor, the Challenger 7. Weighing in at 9.7oz for a U.S. men’s size 9.5, it remains lightweight for a trail running shoe, which typically weigh more due to their robust outsoles.

The upper is crafted from a breathable mesh material, designed to offer comfort and protection, especially with its toe bumper. While it excels in comfort, more protection on the sides and front would benefit those who run on uneven, rocky trails.

Performance on Varied Terrain

The midsole of the Challenger 8 utilizes a compression-moulded EVA foam, akin to that found in the Hoka Clifton 10. This material is soft and supportive over long distances, though it lacks significant energy return. Runners may find that the mild rocker design promotes a smooth transition through miles on even ground, while sidewalls provide stability. However, the Challenger 8 may feel less stable compared to more technical trail shoes, especially on jagged rocky terrain.

During extensive testing—approximately 40 miles across diverse trails and roads—the Challenger 8 showcased its versatility. The shoe performed well on groomed dirt paths and more rugged environments, such as the Forest of Bowland in the U.K. Its adaptability allows runners to confidently tackle unknown terrains, making it an ideal choice for those who enjoy exploring.

Despite its strengths, the Challenger 8 is not without limitations. The soft midsole and stack height may feel unstable on rocky sections, suggesting that specialized trail shoes like the Speedgoat 6 are better suited for such conditions. Nonetheless, for mixed runs, the Challenger 8 excels, offering a smooth experience even at faster paces.

The shoe also doubles effectively as a hiking companion for less challenging terrains, providing comfort during urban walks.

In summary, the Hoka Challenger 8 stands out for its versatility, making it a valuable addition to any runner’s footwear rotation. It offers a reliable option for those who split their time between road and off-road running. While there are more specialized shoes available for specific conditions, the Challenger 8 remains a recommendable choice for those seeking an adaptable running or hiking shoe.