Rare Condos in New York City’s Hidden Pomander Walk Now Available

Two unique condos in Pomander Walk, a secluded neighborhood in Manhattan, are now on the market for a combined price of $1.39 million. This hidden gem, characterized by its European-style cottages, offers a rare opportunity for buyers seeking a distinctive living experience near Central Park. Nestled between 94th and 95th Street, Pomander Walk has remained largely unnoticed by many city residents despite its charm and historical significance.

Founded in 1921 by Irish immigrant Thomas Healy, Pomander Walk was originally intended to be a single large residential building. However, due to financial constraints, it evolved into a picturesque collection of 27 Tudor-style homes. The area was designated a New York City landmark in 1982, further solidifying its unique status within the bustling metropolis.

Listing agent Kim Shankman describes the neighborhood as “a hidden gem,” emphasizing its surprising tranquility so close to the heart of the city. Many who visit the street find it hard to believe they are still in New York City, given its distinct ambiance. The two condos for sale are located on the second and third floors and can be combined into a larger duplex, making them an appealing option for potential buyers.

The two one-bedroom units, which each encompass approximately 500 square feet, are being sold separately for $699,000. Each unit features a living room, an eat-in kitchen, a bathroom, and closets. The current owners have retained the properties for over three decades, and Shankman noted that it is uncommon for units in this area to become available, as most owners tend to hold onto their homes for long periods.

According to StreetEasy, only six units have been listed for rent since 2009, highlighting the rarity of this opportunity. The last recorded sale in the neighborhood was a two-bedroom unit that sold for $900,000 in 2023.

Pomander Walk draws its name from the 1910 play “Pomander Walk,” which is set in England and features a single backdrop reminiscent of the charming street. The neighborhood’s architecture and design reflect a serene escape from the urban environment, making it an attractive prospect for those looking to invest in New York City’s real estate market.

With the recent renovations completed in 2009, Pomander Walk won a “Building Rehabilitation” award from the architecture and culture nonprofit Landmark West, further enhancing its appeal. As the market for these condos opens up, prospective buyers have a chance to own a piece of this idyllic community, which continues to maintain its unique character amidst the vibrant energy of Manhattan.